The short version: Gil sold fifty lifetime licenses and collected $20,000 before he wrote a line of code. The founders of Setai collected a $500 deposit from a company while their product was still a landing page and a fake voice demo. Din generated $65,000 in three days with a lifetime deal. Collecting is the loud part. This article is about the quiet parts too: how each of them found buyers, what the offer looked like, what refund clause they wrote into it — and what they owed the moment the money landed.
I pulled every pre-sale in Starter Story's 100 founder interviews into one table. Nine formats showed up. Six of them brought in money. Three brought the next best thing: a test audience, a booked date, or a distribution deal. All nine collected something before they had a finished product.
Why does a pre-sale beat a waitlist?
A pre-sale means someone pays you before the product exists — a deposit, a license, a pre-order. A waitlist means someone gives you an email address. The distance between those two is the distance between interest and commitment.
The founders in this dataset kept drawing the same line. Teimmo, who built the AI sales agent Setai with Joseph, put it plainly:
"Nothing validates your idea more than someone swiping their credit card."
Din, who built Supergrow, went further. He had tried free users first, and they taught him what free signals are worth:
"Free users don't actually validate your product. They will just consume it, and if something doesn't work they will just ghost you. But customers, because they have put real money into your business, they are going to give you good feedback."
On the other side of the same line, Aayush, the founder of Elephas, described a pattern he sees across the indie scene:
"Lots of people build something in silence for six months, have a waitlist on a free sign-up... they think that automatically — build it and they'll come — and nobody buys."
His diagnosis is not about demand. It is about fear: "People are too afraid to charge, too afraid to put up a real buy button."
A waitlist measures interest. A payment measures intent. Someone willing to pay is the clearest sign you actually helped them — and the strongest validation of your idea.
What are the 9 ways founders actually pre-sold?
Every format below comes from the same dataset, and every number is the founder's own figure at the time of the interview.
# | Format | Founder / product | What they did | What came in |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
1 |
Concept mockup pre-sale |
Gil / Subscribr |
Mocked up the product, sold 50 lifetime licenses, priced the first 10 "super cheap" and raised the price every 10 sold |
$20,000 in 2–3 days, before any code |
|
2 |
Refundable deposit |
Joseph & Teimmo / Setai |
Landing page + SEO keywords + a sales call, then a $500 fully refundable deposit to lock a spot in the first launch |
First $500 before the product existed |
|
3 |
Lifetime deal on a platform |
Din / Supergrow |
Sold lifetime licenses through the lifetime-deal platform RocketHub, 3-day window, capped at 300 users |
$65,000 in 3 days (the platform took 40%) |
|
4 |
Private lifetime deal |
Mike / Frill |
Sold a lifetime deal directly through Reddit groups, Facebook groups, and X — no platform involved |
About $30,000 raised |
|
5 |
Waitlist-first launch |
Lara Costa & Jake / Cleo |
Built a waitlist with LinkedIn content, made the product waitlist-only, then opened a launch with 500 spots at 50% off for life |
$30,000 in recurring revenue in 4 days |
|
6 |
Fake demo content test |
Alejandro & Mario / PushScroll |
Posted a fake product demo on TikTok before building anything, with a closing question: would you use this? |
80,000 views, 500 comments begging for the app |
|
7 |
Commitment metric |
Brian Shin / Once |
Set a rule: 10 events with an actual date and an actual commitment, before writing a single line of code |
4 events from friends + 12 from cold DMs |
|
8 |
Sell the service first |
Vikash / Bulk Mockup |
Did a 30-minute Photoshop job that was quoted at 3–4 days, then offered the client the script itself |
$300 from one client |
|
9 |
Trade equity for distribution |
Hassam / Launch Fast |
Built the MVP in 48 hours, then gave 50% equity to a coaching company for instant access to its audience |
Customers on day zero; $21,800 MRR by day 90 |
Nine formats, one shared trait: none of them sold software. They sold a concept, a spot, a date, a script, or a deal. The software was the thing that arrived later.

How do you find your first buyers?
Five channels did most of the work in this dataset. Each one starts with an action you can take this week.
1. Build the audience before the product. Gil's playbook has four steps, and the first is not research — it is attention. He opened a fresh X account with zero followers, followed everyone in his niche, gave away free tools, and ran viral giveaways until he had an email list of "over a thousand people." Then he talked to that list every week, one-to-one.
"Step three is you've got to do the math on what validation would look like for you. In my case I knew I needed to make about $20,000 to fund, let's say, three months of my life. So I worked out how many people I would need based on my target price point... and that led me to 50 people to buy."
*First step: pick the platform your buyers already use and post one useful thing this week. Then run the same math — your number, your price, your buyer count.*
2. Turn content into a waitlist — and keep it closed. Cleo's team posted LinkedIn content that taught instead of pitched, and drove demand to a waitlist. The product was not purchasable: "You cannot physically buy the product — you need to join a waitlist." They sent more than ten emails before the drop, then opened 500 spots.
*First step: write one post that answers a question your buyer is already asking. No call to action. Just the answer.*
3. Intercept search intent. Setai found buyers through SEO. Their step two: a landing page, plus research on the keywords buyers would search. Then a Calendly link put a face on the call, and the deposit was asked for live.
*First step: search the phrase "[competitor] alternative" and see what comes up. That search result is a pre-sale page you haven't written yet.*
4. Go through your contacts, then cold-DM the rest. Brian's process is the most copyable thing in the dataset. He opened X, LinkedIn, and Instagram side by side and went through every friend, circling anyone with an event coming up. That produced four commitments. Then he searched Instagram hashtags — #wedding, #birthdayparty — and sent 250 to 300 two-sentence messages. Fifteen people replied. Twelve events were booked.
*First step: open your three social apps and write down every person you know who has an event, a launch, or a deadline in the next month.*
5. Borrow someone else's distribution. Hassam had no audience and no way to reach customers, so he gave up half his equity for access to someone else's. His reasoning was blunt: "50% of $20K MRR is better than 50% of zero MRR."
*First step: list the communities, newsletters, or agencies that already own your buyers. One of them can be your distribution.*
What should your pre-sale offer include?
Five patterns held across the strongest offers in the dataset.
1. Price on a ladder, not a flat line. Gil built a ladder on purpose: "The first 10 licenses were super super cheap and then every 10 after that went up." The early prices were so low they "might have not even been profitable" — the point wasn't profit; it was proof that people would say yes. Supergrow used three tiers — $79, $199, $299. Floa used three tiers of its own — $109, $199, $349 — where the cheaper tiers exist to help sell the most expensive one: in the founder's words, they "create a sort of reference."
2. Discount in a way you can keep. Cleo's promise was a one-time trade: "50% off for a lifetime — if you buy now, you will never have to pay the newer price ever again." It is a discount you give once and never negotiate again.
3. Set a real limit. Supergrow's deal ran for three days and was capped at 300 users. Cleo opened 500 spots. Floa's window was five to seven days, which the founder chose because, in his words, it "forces people to make a decision instead of procrastinating." None of these were countdown theater. They were true capacity limits.
4. Decide the refund clause — both answers worked. Gil offered the most generous version: money back at any point before delivery, plus two weeks of trial after it. Setai's version was a 100% refundable deposit. Floa went the other way and said so on the launch page: "There is absolutely no refund." The founder was open about the gaps and told hesitant buyers to wait for the subscription instead. Opposite clauses, same outcome: people bought. A refund clause is not paperwork. It is the thing that makes people willing to pay early. It protects your buyer, and it comes from genuine care for them.
5. Non-cash commitments count too. Brian's bar was ten events with real dates — no money involved. His reasoning: "We thought that was already a big enough commitment that it was almost proxy to a payment." For high-ticket B2B, Teimmo's version of the same idea was stricter: charge "something serious, so you know they are in" — his example was $500 against a tool that would eventually sell for thousands per month.

What are you promising — and what if you can't deliver?
The moment the money lands, the deal changes shape. You are no longer testing an idea. You owe a date.
Gil understood this in advance, and built the pressure into the deal on purpose:
"I told people at any point in time you can ask for your money back. I'm going to deliver this product to you in 60 days, and after that you'll have 2 weeks to continue trying it and ask for your money back. So if I didn't get this right, all that money that I worked for would be lost — and I had 60 days to just put my head down and make the thing happen."
The refund window was not a legal formality. It was the reason strangers were willing to pay him first:
"I wanted to give people total security and comfort in their purchase... they had the confidence in knowing that they could get their money back."
When you take the money, you are not selling software. You are selling a delivery date.
Now the honest part. In 100 interviews, nobody described a delivery failure, a refund wave, or a buyer dispute. That silence is a gap in the dataset, not a guarantee of safety. What the founders do show is the countermeasure: the ones who took money early had already decided what happened if they missed. Gil's was 60 days and a penalty he could not afford — so he built the product. Setai's was a deposit you could reclaim from minute one.
The move for your own pre-sale: set the delivery date by working backward from what you can actually ship, not forward from what sounds impressive. Then keep the first round small enough that a full refund would sting — not ruin you.

When does pre-selling go wrong?
Three failure modes showed up close to the pre-sale line, and they are worth reading before you copy anything above.
Failure mode | What happened | Who |
|---|---|---|
|
Free signals that never convert |
A web app with a free trial and a build-in-public audience got interest — "but it never really turned into any real dollars." The fix was a product change: desktop app, one-time purchase, no AI costs. It went on to do $80,000 in six months. |
Prrenit / Canvas Mode |
|
A lifetime deal that keeps costing |
The lifetime deal brought $65,000 in three days. It also brought a 40% platform cut, angry customers filing feature requests, and a crowd of what the founder called "cheap customers." His summary: "It sort of gives the perception your product is not that great." |
Din / Supergrow |
|
Crowding out your own pricing |
A waitlist that never gets a real price — or a real buy button — teaches your audience to wait forever. |
Aayush / Elephas (pattern, not a personal case) |
The dataset is thin exactly where you would want it to be thick. Nobody in 100 interviews shared a story about running a pre-sale that failed. The failures in the dataset are mostly the opposite kind: products built in silence, launched to nobody. That absence tells you something about survivorship — everyone who gets interviewed made it, and the people who refunded their way out of a pre-sale are not on the guest list.
So treat this page as a machine, not a guarantee. The machine is real. The odds are not published.
FAQ
Is pre-selling the same as crowdfunding?
No. Crowdfunding pools strangers on a platform with all-or-nothing rules and a public pitch. Every case here sold directly — to an email list, a waitlist, a community, or a set of sales calls. The common thread is narrower: payment precedes the product.
How much should I charge in a pre-sale?
Enough that a yes means something to your buyer. Teimmo's rule for high-ticket products: don't charge $20, charge something serious. Gil went the other direction on the low end: the first ten licenses were priced for proof, not profit — their job was showing that people would say yes at all. Both worked. The number should match the commitment you are asking for.
What if nobody buys my pre-sale?
The dataset can't answer this one honestly — no founder in it described that outcome. What the material does support: the cost of finding out is one week, not six months, and the signal shows up early. If the warm-up emails get opened and nobody replies, you already have your answer.
Do I need an audience to pre-sell?
Nobody in this dataset started with one. Gil built his from a zero-follower account. Cleo built a waitlist with educational content. Frill sold into Reddit and Facebook communities. Hassam borrowed a distribution channel and paid for it in equity. The list can be built, borrowed, or rented. It just cannot be skipped.
What happens to buyers if I never finish the product?
This is the question the refund clause answers, and it is why the clause matters more than the discount. Gil's structure — refundable at any time before delivery, plus a trial window after — let strangers trust him with $20,000. If your plan involves consumer law in your market, talk to a professional. This article is not legal advice.
---
One more thing. The nine formats, the five offer rules, and the refund comparison are in a one-page checklist I put together from the interviews. Free, just an email.
---
Related reading
- How to Find a SaaS Idea That Actually Makes Money
- How to Find a SaaS Idea Without an Audience
- Why Do Side Projects Fail?
*Source note: every case in this article comes from Starter Story's founder interviews. I went through 100 of them and checked every load-bearing number against the original transcripts. All results are self-reported.*




No comments yet